Dear Dr. Hortfreud, I found an old newspaper clipping..

Dear Dr. Hortfreud,

I need your help!

I found a yellowed newspaper clipping stuck in the pages of an old gardening book I bought last week, and it has sent me straight down a rabbit hole where the gardening advice is always curious and the people are interesting.

I am blaming Hortense for giving me a little push, or perhaps it was a giant shove down this particular rabbit hole, the likes of which I do not really have time for. She was the one who wrote and suggested that I look in old gardening books for some information that I can't seem to find anywhere else.

No, Dr. Hortfreud, I don't know who Geraldine or her mother are, though someone has signed the book "Mrs. H. A. Sherrill". I am not really interested in them. Instead, I want to know more about the author of the garden column, Marguerite Smith. Where was she from and when did she write it?

There was an engagement announcement on the back of the clipping about a couple with Indianapolis addresses, so likely the garden column was from an Indianapolis paper and so was Marquerite.

Then I checked in with my favorite genealogist-gardener, Annie in Austin, with the name of the couple listed in the engagement announcement and the month and day they planned to marry and she quickly wrote back that they got married in 1945. That probably means my newspaper clipping is 66 years old.

I also checked in with my favorite newspaper-junkie, former reporter now garden columnist for the Indianapolis Star, the Hoosier Gardener, to find out if she recognized the name Marguerite Smith and she did. In fact, she also has an old newspaper clipping of one of Marguerite's columns that she found tucked in an old book that belonged to her mother. She believes that Marguerite once wrote a garden column for the Indianapolis Star. Or was it the now defunct Indianapolis Times which ceased publication in 1965?

After more checking online, I discovered that Marguerite wrote an article for the American Rose Society on Rose Society Publicity. Frass! They only offer snippets of the publication so I only know how she started the article.

"The newspapers are, of necessity, full of bad news in these troubled..."

We could use that opening line today, couldn't we?

Anyway, as much as I was frustrated that I could not read the article in its entirety, it did give me proof that Marguerite was once the garden editor for the Indianapolis Times. Further proof came in the form of another article that someone posted as a PDF online

But what good is all of this information? And did Marguerite ever write for the Indianapolis Star? The answer appears to be no, but she did write for the Indianapolis News, published by the same organization. I figured that out from this one line from an online database of obituaries provided by the state of Indiana: "Smith, Marguerite R. Walters (Mrs. Leland R.) / Death. Former garden editor of Indianapolis Times and Indianapolis News. Indpls. Star. Jan. 4, 1990. Sec. B. p. 4, c. 4"

And there my search ended, at least for now. It is summertime and there is too much to do above ground in the garden and too many places to go to spend much time running around in rabbit holes looking for obscure references to long forgotten garden writers, as fun as that sounds.

Dr. Hortfreud, though I found some interesting information in these old books and this newspaper column, it doesn't really get me any closer to finding out about the Green Bandana Garden Club.

Or does it? Writing this letter has helped me pull myself out of the rabbit hole, dust myself off, clarify my thinking, and figure out my next move.

Thank you as always for listening (reading), Dr. H.



  1. Time travel! I love it! Maruerite must have been a good garden writer to have people clipping her articles and saving them in books. Does her advice still hold true today, one wonders? And will our blog posts still be read 50+ years from now?


  2. Rabbit holes can be a lot of fun and give us even more things to look into. It's good you have a good listener and advisor like Dr H to bounce ideas off.

  3. I love when I find an old clipping in a book.

    It's like a little peek into what the previous owner found important! A little look at their life.


  4. Such a nice thing to think of that gardener reaching out over the years.My first thought was...and she just died recently! Until I did the math.

  5. Very cute post - and interesting search possibilities! Love the name Dr. Hertfreud. :-)

  6. Oh, I am waiting on the edge of my sofa for the next installment!

  7. I love those history rabbit holes. Just fascinating.

  8. I might be able to track down a copy of the article about Rose Society Publicity... I've ordered the article from the Royal Library here in Copenhagen, so we'll see if they can find it. (They should have all editions of that magazine 1933-1962, so volume 11 with the article should be 1944, which would fit nicely with the newspaper clipping...)

    I'll get a pdf to you if I get hold of it!

  9. What a find! But I have to wonder with Frances, will our blogs be read in 50 years? It is the beauty of print that it does last forever it seems. No worries of technology changing so much that things become obsolete in just a few years.


Post a Comment

Comments are to a blog what flowers are to a garden. Sow your thoughts here and may all your comments multiply as blooms in your garden.

Though there is never enough time to respond to each comment individually these days, please know that I do read and love each one and will try to reciprocate on your blog.

By the way, if you are leaving a comment just so you can include a link to your business site, the garden fairies will find it and compost it!