Killing is for weeds

I've never killed a plant I purposely planted in my garden.

Sadly, sometimes those plants die on me, for either an inexplicable or explicable reason.

I do cringe a little when the reason is explicable.

Perhaps I put the plant in a less than ideal location, expecting a plant that likes wet feet to adapt to dry conditions or vice versa.  Or maybe I planted those two opposites side by side and then tried to compromise on the watering, resulting in one plant begging for a life jacket to keep from drowning and the other plant holding up its empty glass, unable to speak on its own behalf because it was so parched.

I imagine at one point those two unlikely neighbors looked at one another, clasped their stems together and like the last passengers on the Titanic, accepted their inevitable fate and died.

But I didn't kill them.

Maybe I put a sun-loving plant in a shady location that I thought got enough sun, which may have been stretching the definition of enough sun, especially since it was a favorite spot for moss to grow. I  didn't kill the plant, I was merely misinformed on its overall willingness to survive in less than ideal conditions.

On a few occasions, by which I mean more occasions than a non-gardener could ever understand, I've dismissed a plant from my garden. I changed my mind about it. Perhaps it got bigger than it should have. Or it had bad habits of self-sowing that no one warned me about. Or maybe it just needed to go because we'd grown apart and I had taken up with a new plant that would be perfect right where that plant was.

Once I dismissed a plant from my garden, which on more than one occasion also required me to emotionally distance myself from that plant, I either waited until it died, or I dug it out, cut it out, tore it out, plucked it out, or grubbed it out. But I never outright killed that plant.

Killing is for weeds, and weeds alone. Every gardener knows weeds must die by our own hands, which implies, of course, that we must kill them.  The methods by which we kill the weeds look quite a bit like the methods we employ to dismiss a plant. We dig them out, tear them out, cut them back, pluck them out or grub them out. We slay them. They are weeds. They must die! Everyone understands this and no one puts the chlorophyll of these plants on the gardener's hands.

But when it comes to the plants we no longer want in our gardens, I refuse to accept that we gardeners kill them. We bid them farewell, we thank them, or we explain why they simply cannot stay in the garden. We may even try to find new homes for them in other gardens.  At the very least, we apologize to them right before we sever their roots. But we don't kill them.

Because killing is for weeds.



  1. Oh, ho, ho, this made me laugh." I imagine at one point those two unlikely neighbors looked at one another, clasped their stems together and like the last passengers on the Titanic, accepted their inevitable fate and died."I have many plants that feel this way. I am removing two roses this weekend because I am tired of their bad habits mostly of grabbing me as I walk by. I'm putting in two skyward or some such thing boxwoods in their place.~~Dee

  2. And sometimes a plant really should give it up but languishes on until it is relegated to the compost heap to provide future sustenance for the garden. I confess....I have killed plants. I take full responsibility.

  3. That is a fine way of deflecting any responsibility for murder. On the other hand pretty darned funny.

  4. I often go to weed my garden and argue with myself about the usefulness of weeds as groundcover and, therefore, should be left alone. I have a garden full of "groundcover" because i cant stand the guilt of weeding.

  5. I'll be the one who admits to killing plants. There, I've said it. I'm not proud of it but I've had to brutally "dismiss" annoyingly invasive plants like St. John's Wort, Lily of the Valley and a type of Euphorbia that spreads and hides in the base of other plants. I wish plant sellers would include an invasiveness rating on their labels. It's a nightmare to have to remove pavers to get at the runners of some plants that decided they needed to be everywhere in my garden. Yeah. I'm a murderer. Sigh.


Post a Comment

Comments are to a blog what flowers are to a garden. Sow your thoughts here and may all your comments multiply as blooms in your garden.

Though there is never enough time to respond to each comment individually these days, please know that I do read and love each one and will try to reciprocate on your blog.

By the way, if you are leaving a comment just so you can include a link to your business site, the garden fairies will find it and compost it!